Listmania!
Jackie Chan's American Movies on DVD--Best to Worst
By an Amazon.com customer
Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood BurnAlan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn
Buy new: $17.99 / Used from: $3.15
# 12 This is the worst of the bunch. In an insulting cameo, Jackie wields a gigantic gun, Bronson style, and actually says "Don't F--- with me!" A case of massive miscasting. In fact, this limp satire on Hollywood was a complete waste of everyone's time.
Cannonball Run 2Cannonball Run 2
Buy new: $10.99 / Used from: $4.99
#11 Basically another insulting cameo. In fact, they had Jackie playing a Japanese character! The career nadir of everyone involved--but especially bad for Jackie, who was a superstar pretending to be an up and comer instead of a second rate star on his way down like everyone else involved.
The Cannonball RunThe Cannonball Run
Buy new: $6.99 / Used from: $2.25
#10 Jackie was misused in exactly the same way in his first Cannonball fiasco. This one is one up the list only because it was the first piece of junk and not a sequel to a piece of junk.
The MedallionThe Medallion
Buy new: $9.95 / Used from: $0.01
#9 A USA/Hong Kong co-production in which Jackie had some creative control, you'd think this would have been better. But Jackie and his Director Gordan Chan only succeded in proving that they didn't understand how to make a good American-style action comedy any better than American filmmakers know how to make a good HK style action flick.
The ProtectorThe Protector
Buy used from: $4.49
# 8 This was the second attempt to make Jackie an action star in the USA. Noted action hack James Glickenhaus took Jackie and tried to turn him into Charles Bronson. Chan was so dissapointed in the results that he reshot the ending and shot additional action and comedy scenes before the film was released in Asia. I would rate Chan's version a couple of rungs higher than I have this version.
The TuxedoThe Tuxedo
Buy new: $9.98 / Used from: $0.50
#7 This was one of Jackie's most "Disney" films. Not bad, not good. A bit too kiddie for the adults but not "kiddie" enough for the wee ones. The lack of Chan style action sequences does give the man a chance to showcase his comedy acting chop, though. A great cameo sequence by the Godfather of Soul James Brown is offset by Jennifer Love Hewitt not performing her shrill part in a bikini.
Battle Creek BrawlBattle Creek Brawl
Buy new: $9.98 / Used from: $3.38
#6 At least this first attempt to make Jackie a USA star was not insulting--just kind of bland. Director Robert Clouse tried to use Chan's charm and comedy skills as well as some of his acrobatic abilities (though they are poorly shot). Set in the depression era, this is one of those low budget 70s flicks where people who live in the 1930s have disco haircuts and flared slacks.
Around the World in 80 Days (Widescreen Edition)Around the World in 80 Days (Widescreen Edition)
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $2.08
# 5 This is a near miss, but a good try. There are a couple of great Jackie Chan style action set pieces and a fine cast (including gorgeous HK superstar Karen Mok, in a rare villainous role). But the director's main claim to fame was not action adventures but Adam Sandler flicks--and the lack of taste and storytelling discipline showed a bit too often.
Shanghai NoonShanghai Noon
Buy new: $9.99 / Used from: $1.44
#4 Jackie gives a great comic performance, and the film was a lot of fun, but there weren't as many elaborate Chan style action sequences as there should have been. Jackie had to work out the his action set pieces on the fly. The filmmakers fought him on it at the time, but had to eat their words when his action sequences were the most popular parts of the film.
Rush Hour (New Line Platinum Series)Rush Hour (New Line Platinum Series)
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $0.25
#3 An unjustly maligned film--by the critics, that is. The public--including myself--strongly disagreed. This was the movie that cemented Chan's US stardom. Though Jackie was for the most part playing a more serious Chinese Dean Martin to Chris Tucker's manic black Jerry Lewis, director Bret Ratner at least seemed to understand who Jackie was and what he could do.
Rush Hour 2 (Special Edition)Rush Hour 2 (Special Edition)
Buy new: $11.49 / Used from: $1.47
#2 Call him a hack, but Brett Ratner is the first American director to let Jackie really be Jackie. Not only was he allowed to be funny and charming, but there are several spectacular classic Chan action set pieces that harken back to his glory days in Hong Kong. Add to that a good cast and some really funny bits and you had a party in the movie theatre that made everyone feel good.
Shanghai KnightsShanghai Knights
Buy new: $8.99 / Used from: $0.73
#1 Far and away Jackie's best American film--in fact it's one of his best, period! Everything here works. Perfect direction, great chemistry between Owen Wilson and Chan, a witty script that still has heart, a top notch cast, lush production. But best of all, the film is chock full of Chan-choreographed sequences of physical comedy and action that rival those of Keaton, Chaplin, and Lloyd.