Product Details

• Amazon Sales Rank: #4854002 in Books
• Published on: 1999-01-01
• Format: Import
• Original language: English
• Binding: Hardcover
• 336 pages

Customer Reviews

Awesome! Bravo! I can't say enough ...
Beyond the wonderful writing, there is amazing plot, divided loyalties, real emotions, intrigue, always unexpected twists, realistic problems filled with drama. I loved this book as much as Robb's previous 'Owen Archer' novels.

The way in which this author manages to convey the thoughts and myriad of motivations behind her characters never ceases to amaze me. Everyone is so real with their own loyalties, and their own interests. Even Owen and Lucie's relationship is made all the more special to this reader because of the true way in which the author conveys their own doubts sometimes about each other, sometimes about themselves. I am enchanted by Wales and Owen's roots there. I'm intrigued by St. David's and the Welsh history of the time.

I can't wait to read the next book. And I'm considering going back to APOTHECARY ROSE and starting all over again. These mysteries are wonderful.

The lady has done much better.
I was a little disappointed in A Spy for the Redeemer. Of all the Owen Archer series, this is definitely my least favorite. In contemplating the causes, I can only say that it seemed to me that the author, Candace Robb, seemed to be trying to fit too many stories into her 300 pages. What seemed two or three short stories about her main characters were intertwined to produce one tale that became "busy" rather than clever. I also felt that she had perhaps gotten tired of her main characters and their relationships, and had tried to introduce other individuals whose stories were still in the developing mode. Following these new personalities made the whole thing seem even more chaotic. The reader had hardly gotten into a theme when the story took off in another direction. While I find Ms Robb's ability to weave more than one tale together skillfully, this seemed to have reached the outer limits of my ability or willingness to follow along with it. I almost didn't finish the book after chapter 6; chapter 7 was aptly entitled "Chaos."

The primary story seems to be that of an attack on Lucie's ancestral home, Freythorpe Hadden, by a group of thieves who seem to have an uncanny knowledge of the great hall that they had invaded. A secondary tale is Lucie's management of a lengthy list of personal problems: a husband whose absence seems to have been prolonged and whose return is in some question, the widower next door whose attentions are flattering but also unsettling to her, a local gossip who has spread tales of malpractice and infidelity, an aunt whose mental stability is constantly changing, an apprentice who is going through pubescence and mood swings, etc., etc. I got exhausted just reading about it all. And I thought my life was chaotic!

Also a major tale is Owen's visit to his homeland, Wales, and his interrupted plans for returning home to his family. The stonemason who had been commissioned to do his father-in-law's tomb is murdered, and the local archdeacon insists Owen must solve the mystery before leaving the country. A secondary tale attached to this subplot is Owen's temptation to remain in Wales to fight for its liberty. His personal torment is that while he dislikes the treatment his brother Welshmen receive at the hands of their arrogant English overlords, he loves his wife and family and has received only good treatment from the English nobility that he has himself served. Furthermore, he knows that the lack of cohesion among the factions in Welsh politics will probably prevent an effective revolt. Even should the rightful heir prevail, his dependence on French support will probably reduce him to the position of mere pawn of King Charles in his on-going wars with the English king Edward over the control of the French throne. Not a hopeful situation.

Again I enjoyed the author's small exposition on the history and sociology of the 14th century at the back of the book. I have taken to reading this before starting the main text because it clarifies the action of the story. Here too, though, the author seems to have lost her usual passion for the period. There are just a few comments on the history of England, France and Wales as it might apply to her own tale and a list of suggested readings.

If I hadn't read the book's successor the Cross-Legged Knight already, I'd have thought the author had lost interest in the period and the characters altogether.

Just okay. The lady has done much better.

Excellent
I have been a fan of Candace Robb's books since first available. The historical detail and the faithfulnes to the period are truly noteworthy. I also applaud her refusal to bow to political correctness and ascribe contemporary values and qualities to 14th century people. This book was a bit disjointed, but other than that, excellent