Listmania!
Desert Island Discs for Christmas Island
By an Amazon.com customer
Tapestry of CarolsTapestry of Carols
Buy new: $19.98 / Used from: $65.66
Strong folk/classic arrangements that sound both fresh and antique, meticulous and handcrafted.
The Story of ChristmasThe Story of Christmas by The Swingle Singers
Buy new: $15.99 / Used from: $13.62
Refined choral sound with some thoughtful contemporary songs in the mix, and a mind-blowing "Boar's Head Carol."
Jessye Norman - ChristmastideJessye Norman - Christmastide by George Frideric Handel
Buy new: $8.97 / Used from: $3.35
Elegant, reverent. Orchestrations are inventive without being gimmicky. Norman sounds exquisite, floating above a boy choir. Musical cross-references connect the songs in a satisfying progression.
The Christmas AlbumThe Christmas Album by The Manhattan Transfer
Buy used from: $0.36
Johnny Mandel arrangements lean toward romantic lushness but are spiked with the tight, swinging energy of "Happy Holiday" and "Santa Claus Is Coming to Town." I keep it out year-round.
A Winter's Solstice IIA Winter's Solstice II by Various Artists
Buy new: $6.99 / Used from: $2.96
The best of the largely instrumental series. Original tunes that blend well with other elegant seasonal fare. Warm, reflective, gentle, candlelit.
ChristmasChristmas by Singers Unlimited
Buy new: $8.97 / Used from: $7.95
Cleanly produced (the four singers sound like they are performing inside your head). Casual, pop-inflected swooping onto the notes. Nice to hear some of the underappreciated Alfred Burt carols.
The Gift: Acoustic Offerings for the Holiday SeasonThe Gift: Acoustic Offerings for the Holiday Season by Eric Tingstad
Buy used from: $13.36
Acoustic instrumentals that are gentle enough for background music, interesting enough for close listening.
For ChristmasFor Christmas by Peter Kater
Buy used from: $3.51
Solo piano. Gentle and modest, often edging toward what you'd hear in a hotel bar, but refreshingly and consistently unpretentious.
Christmas with Chanticleer (Featuring Dawn Upshaw)Christmas with Chanticleer (Featuring Dawn Upshaw)
Buy new: $14.99 / Used from: $6.95
The guys vary their diction to match the wide-ranging musical traditions (classical, gospel, folk). A Tavener piece is uncharacteristically catchy and rhythmic. The Distler unfolds like rose petals.
We Three KingsWe Three Kings by The Roches
Buy used from: $23.80
Fun, fun, fun! Lots of tracks, hilarious Joisey accent on "Winter Wonderland." Two thoughtful, pretty original tunes.