Listmania!
Catholic Cinema: The Good, The Bad, and . . . the Lukewarm . . . .
By an Amazon.com customer
St. Teresa of AvilaSt. Teresa of Avila
Buy new: $35.99
Best Catholic film of all time, hands down.
A Man for All Seasons (Special Edition)A Man for All Seasons (Special Edition)
Buy new: $11.49 / Used from: $7.09
Fine screenplay and extraordinary performances in this critical drama for English-speaking Catholics.
The Exorcist (The Version You've Never Seen)The Exorcist (The Version You've Never Seen)
Buy new: $7.99 / Used from: $1.99
Yes, The Exorcist -- one of best presentations of Catholic viewpoint ever presented by Hollywood. Gritty realism and tough look at American life saves this film from damage caused by a couple big flaws (ie, spinning head, some blasphemy mostly for shock value). See only in this excellent restored edition.
Romero (IMPORT)Romero (IMPORT)
Buy used from: $6.67
Convincing and engaged.
Exorcist II: The Heretic (Snap Case)Exorcist II: The Heretic (Snap Case)
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $1.25
A truly BAD film .. which nonetheless has the benefit of straightforwardly revealing exactly how looney is the theology of Theihard de Chardin ... which this film is based upon.
The Miracle of Our Lady of FatimaThe Miracle of Our Lady of Fatima
Buy new: $13.99 / Used from: $9.57
Sentimental mediocrity ... reduces major mystical event of century 20 to lukewarm schmaltz.
The Song of BernadetteThe Song of Bernadette
Buy new: $9.99 / Used from: $5.50
Dittos re the major mystical event of century 19.
Pope John Paul IIPope John Paul II
Buy new: $17.49 / Used from: $10.99
Good in parts, particularly wartime Poland scenes. Later JP2 is earnestly portrayed by Voight, but the fact is the man was an enormously complex personality with shadows, which the film doesn't even suggest. Simply, bits of factual truth, but hardly aims at The Whole Truth.
Going My Way (Universal Cinema Classics)Going My Way (Universal Cinema Classics)
Buy new: $10.99 / Used from: $5.98
Most popular American Catholic film of century 20, pure entertainment and saved by simplicity of spirit.
The Bells of St. Mary'sThe Bells of St. Mary's
Buy new: $14.98 / Used from: $18.08
For those who just can't get enough of the old singing priest business . . . .
The Passion of the Christ (Definitive Edition)The Passion of the Christ (Definitive Edition)
Buy new: $18.49 / Used from: $6.19
Flawed but doggedly orthodox. The truth is, a great film about Jesus Christ is simply not possible.
HamletHamlet
Buy new: $5.79 / Used from: $4.99
Franco Zefferrili's direction captures the Catholic essence of this famous play -- the hero's struggle with his own conscience regarding moral action, egged on by encounter with his murdered king-father in Purgatory.
The Agony and the EcstasyThe Agony and the Ecstasy
Buy new: $6.99 / Used from: $3.97
The best Catholic film from the old epic/blockbuster days, saved by extraordinary performance of Rex Harrison as Pope Julius and essentially sound, unflinching realism of script.
The Exorcist 3The Exorcist 3
Buy new: $7.49 / Used from: $0.36
Just plain BAD ... so I know there must be a redeemable feature of it ... I just haven't figured it out yet (after 3 viewings).
The Mission (Two-Disc Special Edition)The Mission (Two-Disc Special Edition)
Buy new: $10.99 / Used from: $11.35
Most tragic and spectacular failure in Catholic film history: 1/2 a great movie, 1/2 a lousy fraud, with no in between (just an invisible wall down the middle).
The Third Man (50th Anniversary Edition) - Criterion CollectionThe Third Man (50th Anniversary Edition) - Criterion Collection
Buy used from: $14.90
While no overt Catholic reference, this great moral drama is the best film of a literary work by a Catholic author (Graham Greene) and on short list of great films of century 20.
Into Great Silence (Two-Disc Set)Into Great Silence (Two-Disc Set)
Buy new: $16.99 / Used from: $18.95
Documentary on the Carthusians, a great and one of a kind film record.
FaustinaFaustina
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $19.95
Surprisingly straightforward and realistic, not a hagiography.
The Nun's StoryThe Nun's Story
Buy new: $5.79 / Used from: $5.18
The pinnacle of the lukewarm: a well made film, expertly enacted, which is totally wrong-headed. Eerily foreshadows the total systemic breakdown in American Catholicism from 60s onward.
Silver Chalice [VHS]Silver Chalice [VHS]
Buy used from: $2.95
One of worst films ever made, this choice wreck from Hollywood's "bible epic" days is based on New Testament apocrypha. Worthwhile as encapsulating in one movie all pitfalls of (1) presenting Jesus & apostles Hollywoodized; (2)for purposes other than teaching the faith; (3) with a lot of extra-testamental nonsense thrown in.
MALCOLM MUGGERIDGEMALCOLM MUGGERIDGE
Buy new: $19.99 / Used from: $16.99
The essential Catholic message presented in a brilliant short film, comprising the spiritual testimony of this famous English convert facing his last days straightforwardly.