Listmania!
Controversial Children's Picture Books
By an Amazon.com customer
Standing UpStanding Up by Marie-Anne Gillet; Isabelle Gilboux
Buy used from: $0.75
A book on a boy learning how to pee, as the title suggests, standing up.
Where Willy WentWhere Willy Went by Nicholas Allan
Buy new: $13.63 / Used from: $6.66
Willy is a fast swimming sperm and this story takes on a rather odd whimsical approach to the baby-making process, though it does provide some insight for youngsters on where babies come from.
In the Night Kitchen (Caldecott Collection)In the Night Kitchen (Caldecott Collection) by Maurice Sendak
Buy new: $12.92 / Used from: $7.99
Challenged because of the little boy shown nude in the story, Sendak's classic has inspired some folks (even librarians) to draw clothes or glue clothes on him!
And Tango Makes ThreeAnd Tango Makes Three by Peter Parnell
Buy new: $11.55 / Used from: $9.79
Based on the true story of two male penguins at the zoo who hatch and raise an orphaned chick, this book might take anthropomorphizing a bit far at times. But this book has folks up in arms for the implications it might have in the human world. Ages 6 and up.
The Un-WeddingThe Un-Wedding by Babette Cole
Buy used from: $0.01
A startlingly different book on divorce where two kids whose parents hate each other have an "unwedding" for them. Not necessarily the most realistic approach to divorce for most.
Goodnight MoonGoodnight Moon by Margaret Wise Brown
Buy new: $8.99 / Used from: $0.01
Yes, this good old classic has a controversy surrounding it: the picture of the author on the back originally had a cigarette in his hand, the publisher digitally erased it from later publications and hubbub ensued in the book community!
The Lorax (Classic Seuss)The Lorax (Classic Seuss) by Dr. Seuss
Buy new: $10.17 / Used from: $5.18
This classic by Dr. Seuess won the ire of the logging industry, who challenged it as negatively portraying said industry in this "tree hugger" book.
Where's Waldo?: ReissueWhere's Waldo?: Reissue by Martin Handford
Buy new: $10.19 / Used from: $2.56
I'm unaware whether the reissue has the challenged pick, but apparently when most folks were looking for Waldo, someone found a lady with her bikini top off . . . furor naturally followed.
The Story of FerdinandThe Story of Ferdinand by Munro Leaf
Buy new: $10.52 / Used from: $4.80
Not a recent controversy, but when Ferdinand came out it was challenged as promoting a pacifist agenda.
Halloween ABCHalloween ABC by Eve Merriam
Buy used from: $3.40
Plenty of Halloween stuff gets challenged on the basis that it includes the occult and/or frightening images for children, this is one of the top challenged picture books on the subject.
The Story of Little Black SamboThe Story of Little Black Sambo by Helen Bannerman
Buy new: $11.55 / Used from: $9.50
Ah, a famous book for controversy, more for the pics than the story, since the boy in the story is actually Indian. Several reworkings of this are available that change the title and the images, but the classic tale still raises eyebrows.
Little Red Riding HoodLittle Red Riding Hood by Trina Schart Hyman
Buy new: $17.95 / Used from: $1.74
I think this is the version that was challenged on the basis of Red Riding Hood having wine in that basket she was taking to grandma . . .
Sylvester and the Magic Pebble (Stories to Go!)Sylvester and the Magic Pebble (Stories to Go!) by William Steig
Buy used from: $0.01
The biggest issue I've heard in regards to this Steig classic is that all the characters are animals of one sort or another. And Steig draws the police as--you guessed it--pigs.
Happy to Be Nappy (Jump at the Sun)Happy to Be Nappy (Jump at the Sun) by bell hooks
Buy used from: $18.75
Another book that's got mixed opinions. The idea of "nappy hair" seems to raise red flags, though the book is a positive image builder for gals that have this sort of hair.
Manneken Pis: A Simple Story of a Boy Who Peed on a WarManneken Pis: A Simple Story of a Boy Who Peed on a War by Vladimir Radunsky
Buy used from: $0.01
Okay, don't know what I think of this book, except that it's definitely a book for boys! About a boy who stops a war by peeing on it.
Pinkerton, Behave!Pinkerton, Behave! by Steven Kellogg
Buy new: $12.23 / Used from: $5.56
Kellog's "bad dog" story may be funny, but many feel the burgaler holding a gun to the mother's head not once, but twice in pictures is just unacceptably scary for a picture book for young children.
The Sissy DucklingThe Sissy Duckling by Harvey Fierstein
Buy new: $6.99 / Used from: $2.94
If you can't tell from the cover, there is a definite gay theme to this story by Harvey Fierstein, but there's also an objection to the use of "Sissy" as a positive thing, as the word is meant as an insult.
A Light in the AtticA Light in the Attic by Shel Silverstein
Buy used from: $5.73
This grandmaster of children's poetry is often challenged for his outrageous and often shocking poems. "Someone Ate the Baby" being an example.
The Amazing Bone (Reading Rainbow Book)The Amazing Bone (Reading Rainbow Book) by William Steig
Buy new: $7.99 / Used from: $0.01
Another Steig on the list! Here there were objections because one of the animal characters uses tobacco.
The Five Chinese Brothers (Paperstar)The Five Chinese Brothers (Paperstar) by Claire Huchet Bishop
Buy new: $5.99 / Used from: $1.68
This story of five brothers with special talents who manage to thwart execution is one I loved as a child. It's a folk tale with many versions, but this version has raised eyebrows because of its violent content, and for the non-PC character depictions.
The Stupids Have a Ball (Sandpiper)The Stupids Have a Ball (Sandpiper) by Harry G. Allard Jr.
Buy new: $6.95 / Used from: $0.97
This is the 27th most censored book on the ALA's top hundred challenged books from 1990-1999. Mostly for depicting family in a derogatory way.
The Rabbits' WeddingThe Rabbits' Wedding by Garth Williams
Buy new: $15.29 / Used from: $4.95
Here's a historical one, this one was put on the reserve shelf in Alabama in 1959 because it depicted a black rabbit marrying a white rabbit. Thus, I suppose, interracial marriage. Wonder what they made of the Owl and the Pussycat . . .
Little ZiziLittle Zizi by Thierry Lenain
Buy new: $14.92 / Used from: $5.99