Listmania!
Not Enough French Revolution Movies
By an Amazon.com customer
Danton [VHS]Danton [VHS]
Buy used from: $7.45
One of the best, though Wajda obviously had a political agenda in turning a pro-Robespierre play into an anti-Robespierre film! More about Poland in 1982 than about France in 1794. But still a marvelous drama. Bring it out on DVD! Please!!!!!!
La Nuit de Varennes [VHS]La Nuit de Varennes [VHS]
Buy used from: $29.99
Some love it, some hate it, but I love this movie. Lots of period color and plenty of humor as the characters, some historical and some fictional, follow the absconding Louis XVI across northeastern France and realize that the world they know is coming to an end and everything is about to change. Bring it out on DVD!!!!!!
The Lady and the DukeThe Lady and the Duke
Buy used from: $2.98
Beautiful to look at, as if the characters are all moving within period paintings. Miss Elliot's royalism may get a bit annoying for those who are fonder of the revolutionaries, but the history and detail is spot-on.
The Affair of the NecklaceThe Affair of the Necklace
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $3.85
An underrated movie, flawed but entertaining. Aside from some clunky bits where the producers obviously messed with the script and demanded that Jeanne be portrayed as a wronged heroine (give me a break!), it's an extremely accurate narrative of one of history's greatest con games. And I'll watch Adrien Brody in anything. :-)
The Scarlet PimpernelThe Scarlet Pimpernel
Buy new: $9.99 / Used from: $14.81
The best of all the various Scarlet Pimpernel movies, with an entertaining script, lush production values, and a great cast.
The Scarlet PimpernelThe Scarlet Pimpernel
Buy used from: $6.71
Typical 30s Hollywooding of a costume romance, but Leslie Howard's performance is always worth seeing. Raymond Massey is nicely creepy (but I prefer Ian McKellen as Chauvelin, myself).
A Tale of Two Cities (Masterpiece Theatre, 1989)A Tale of Two Cities (Masterpiece Theatre, 1989)
Buy new: $25.49 / Used from: $20.09
Arguably the best filming of the classic novel. The only film version that really understands the fact that TTC is a serious novel and not a sentimental romance. Plus it's the only version that has grasped that Charles MUST be presented sympathetically or else we don't give a damn if anyone rescues him or not. IMHO, Madame Defarge is horrendously miscast, but the rest of the cast is superb.
A Tale of Two Cities (1935)A Tale of Two Cities (1935)
Buy new: $16.49 / Used from: $6.98
Classic and wonderful, despite its occasional wanderings into thundering French Rev clichés (and compressing the first four years of the Revolution into what feels like about three weeks). One of those perfect MGM casts and Ronald Colman is the best Sydney Carton ever, ever, ever.
A Tale of Two Cities [VHS]A Tale of Two Cities [VHS]
Buy used from: $11.69
Somehow this film gets everything wrong. The script adaptation is botched, nearly every actor is badly miscast (except for Dirk Bogarde, who is excellent as Sydney), and the Revolution, as usual, plunges into the Terror a few days after the Bastille falls. The worst offense is the writing and casting of Charles as a smug, snooty prig; I’d cheer this guy on to the guillotine and keep Sydney.
Tale of Two Cities: Literary Masterpieces [VHS]Tale of Two Cities: Literary Masterpieces [VHS]
Buy used from: $7.07
A humdrum adaptation of the classic. Not particularly bad, but not very good either. Chris Sarandon makes an attractive, likable Charles, but a dreary Sydney. See it for Billie Whitelaw as the most perfect Madame Defarge ever.
SadeSade
Buy new: $17.49 / Used from: $7.05
Creepy but well-presented semifictional account of the ex-Marquis de Sade's stay in the Picpus prison during the last weeks of the Terror. From a French novel that is partly based on Sade's novel "Philosophy in the Boudoir." Daniel Auteuil is always excellent.
QuillsQuills
Buy new: $9.49 / Used from: $1.98
Pretentious nonsense. Watch Marat/Sade instead.
Marat / SadeMarat / Sade
Buy used from: $20.00
Excellent filming of the classic 1960s radical stage production, in which the inhabitants of a lunatic asylum in 1808 re-create the murder of Marat. Scary, creepy, and thrilling.
Marie AntoinetteMarie Antoinette
Buy new: $17.99 / Used from: $8.31
The script of this old warhorse gets lots of tiny historical details right (probably lifted straight from Zweig's biography) and then gets all the big facts (like history) really wrong. Antoinette and family seem to go from Versailles to Varennes to the Temple within six months. Robert Morley is very good as sad-sack Louis, but I doubt that even the real Louis XVI was THAT unattractive!
Marie AntoinetteMarie Antoinette
Buy new: $11.99 / Used from: $2.43
Haven't gotten around to seeing this one yet, but it sounds . . . interesting.
Jefferson in ParisJefferson in Paris
Buy new: $9.99 / Used from: $8.07
Pretty to look at, with a little bit of 1789 stuck in, but way too slow and way too long.
ScaramoucheScaramouche
Buy new: $15.99 / Used from: $10.60
Ghastly 1950s Hollywood trashing of an intelligent novel. The story, which is just fine as it is, got messed with, the acting (except for Stewart Granger and Mel Ferrer) is mostly awful, and the costumes, hair, and makeup...well, the mind boggles. This is 1789 France from 1950 Hollywood via Disney. This story badly needs a remake! I suggest Adrien Brody as André--Adrien, are you listening?
The Black BookThe Black Book
Buy new: $7.98 / Used from: $3.31
Watch this one only when you need a good belly laugh. The Terror as film noir, with ladies in 1940s hairdos. And nobody seems to be able to pronounce French names.
Orphans of the StormOrphans of the Storm
Buy new: $7.98 / Used from: $3.91
A grand achievement when it was made in the 1920s, but now it's mostly good for giggles. Every French Rev cliché known to the movies is in this one, and movie buffs will even recognize Lucille LaVerne, who played Mme Defarge's horrible sidekick in the 1935 Tale of Two Cities, playing the exact same character in this flick. Might be a good party movie for a bunch of drunken Rev fans...