Listmania!
A Beginner's Wagner Collection in Great Sound
By an Amazon.com customer
Wagner: Der fliegende HolländerWagner: Der fliegende Holländer
Buy used from: $12.00
A beautiful and powerful performance from Klemperer, the New Philharmonia, Adam, Talvela and Anja Silja: her one and only great performance.
Wagner: Der fliegende HolländerWagner: Der fliegende Holländer
Buy new: $23.98 / Used from: $11.99
A strong and yet strangely unknown second recommendation with an impassioned "Senta" from Lisbeth Balslev and a thoroughly convincing "Holländer" from Simon Estes, all in fantastic modern Bayreuth sound. Leidenschaftlich!
LohengrinLohengrin
Buy used from: $35.00
A fantastic superstar-studded recording that will never be equalled... certainly not bettered in our lifetime. An inspired Jess Thomas makes Lohengrin his own. Stupendous!
Richard Wagner: LohengrinRichard Wagner: Lohengrin
Buy new: $44.98 / Used from: $33.44
A very stylish second recommendation with the angelic Elsa of Gundula Janowitz and the commanding Lohengrin of James King. Kubelik's Wagner conducting is simply ravishing!
Tristan Und IsoldeTristan Und Isolde
Buy new: $34.99 / Used from: $18.95
There will never be a Tristan und Isolde like this again... never! Windgassen and Nilsson give the performance of their lives. Simply unbelievable! Listen and give thanks.
Wagner: Tristan und IsoldeWagner: Tristan und Isolde
Buy new: $34.99 / Used from: $21.41
A vibrant second recommendation that will not disappoint. You can always depend on Kleiber to produce a winner (Kleiber's Der Freischütz and Beethoven's Fifth are also great classics).
Wagner - Die Meistersinger von Nurnberg / Kollo · Donath · Adam · G. Evans · Schreier ·  Hesse· Riderbusch · KarajanWagner - Die Meistersinger von Nurnberg / Kollo · Donath · Adam · G. Evans · Schreier · Hesse· Riderbusch · Karajan by Richard Wagner
Buy new: $46.98 / Used from: $19.50
Undoubtedly one of Karajan's greatest recordings and one of the greatest recordings of Die Meistersinger I've ever heard! Surely Theo Adam's greatest performance. Completely unsurpased!
Wagner: Die Meistersinger von NürnbergWagner: Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg
Buy new: $57.98 / Used from: $100.68
As with Kubelik's stunning Lohengrin, his Meistersinger just feels so "right" in every way. Simply beautiful singing and imaculate conducting. A very strong second recommendation.
Wagner: ParsifalWagner: Parsifal
Buy new: $47.98 / Used from: $33.33
Knappertsbusch literally owned Parsifal during his long lifetime and one listen to this classic recording will explain why. A phenomenal acheivment and a chance to really hear the unique 1950s-60s Bayreuth acoustic. Otherworldly!
Wagner: ParsifalWagner: Parsifal
Buy used from: $43.69
A sublime and altogether passionate performance from Kubelik, the BRSO and a remarkable cast of singers! Kubelik, once again, finds all the right tempos. A very satisfying second alternative.
Wagner - Der Ring des Nibelungen (Ring Cycle) / Sir Georg SoltiWagner - Der Ring des Nibelungen (Ring Cycle) / Sir Georg Solti by Sir Georg Solti
Buy new: $147.99 / Used from: $89.95
This is the greatest Ring recording ever! Fantastic 1960's Decca sound, stupendous cast, unbelievable conducting; any questions? If you can afford only one (and the 14CD Ring is an expensive proposition), This is the Ring to own and cherish.
Wagner: Der Ring des Nibelungen [Box Set]Wagner: Der Ring des Nibelungen [Box Set]
Buy new: $88.99 / Used from: $50.00
Slightly less expensive but a close second to the above Ring recommendation in good Bayreuth sound. Böhm & company are simply magnificent! Probably the best Walküre on record (the opening wind storm will scare you too!).
Wagner: Der Ring des Nibelungen--Great Scenes / SoltiWagner: Der Ring des Nibelungen--Great Scenes / Solti
Buy new: $11.98 / Used from: $3.30
If the prospect of listening through 14 ”Ring” CDs seems a bit daunting, this is an excellent introduction to Solti's mighty Decca Ring. 1 CD packed with glorious music at super-bargain price. Just do it!
Schubert: Symphony No 9; Wagner / Solti, Vienna Philharmonic OrchestraSchubert: Symphony No 9; Wagner / Solti, Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra
Buy new: $11.98 / Used from: $4.83
Two last recommendations: this one for the achingly beautiful Siegfried Idyll played by a chamber-size VPO and conducted by the indomitable Georg Solti. Grace, passion and Viennese beauty beyond measure.
Wagner: Wesendonck Lieder & Isoldes Liebestod/Brahms: Alto Rhapsody/Mahler: 5 Lieder - Christa Ludwig, Otto Klemperer, Philharmonia OrchestraWagner: Wesendonck Lieder & Isoldes Liebestod/Brahms: Alto Rhapsody/Mahler: 5 Lieder - Christa Ludwig, Otto Klemperer, Philharmonia Orchestra
Buy new: $11.98 / Used from: $7.26
The amazing Christa Ludwig - the greatest Brangäne, Fricka and Ortrud ever! - sings Wagner's ethereal Wesendonck Lieder, accompanied by the New Philharmonia and conducted by Otto Klemperer! Sehr schön deutsche kunst!