Listmania!
Round Up #4
By an Amazon.com customer
Broken LanceBroken Lance
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $4.97
**** - Broken Arrow meets King Lear in Edward Dmytryk's entertaining western.  Spencer Tracy and Richard Widmark are particularly good.
CockfighterCockfighter
Buy used from: $19.99
**** - Warren Oates nails it in this low-budget, sometimes brutal, character study from the early 70s.
Cody! - An Evening With Buffalo BillCody! - An Evening With Buffalo Bill
Buy new: $17.99 / Used from: $8.27
*** - One-man show presentation of the life and times of the creator of the Wild West Show.  Interesting, if a little static.
Custer of the WestCuster of the West
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $0.95
** - Less-than-grand review of the Son of the Morning Star.  Beware full screen only copies.
Dark CommandDark Command
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $6.23
***** - Raoul Walsh directs a young John Wayne in this action packed and entaining look at the William Quantrill legend.
Drums Along the MohawkDrums Along the Mohawk
Buy new: $10.49 / Used from: $6.49
***** - John Ford's classic story of Revolutionary War-era frontier conflict looks great in restored Technicolor print.
Five Bloody GravesFive Bloody Graves
Buy used from: $6.99
** - Cheap drive-in western from the early '70s doesn't have much going for it besides pretty scenery and some recognizable faces.
Great Wacky Western Comedies (The Wackiest Wagon Train In The West / Fair Play / The Terror Of Tiny Town)Great Wacky Western Comedies (The Wackiest Wagon Train In The West / Fair Play / The Terror Of Tiny Town)
Buy used from: $17.74
** - Four stars for Terror of Tiny Town, the other two are simply bad made-for-tv movies from the '70s.
In Old ArizonaIn Old Arizona
Buy new: $9.98 / Used from: $3.42
**** - Good early-talkie western features Warner Baxter in his Oscar-winning role as the Cisco Kid.
Johnson County WarJohnson County War
Buy new: $6.99 / Used from: $2.51
*** - Overlong and overblown ranch war western stars Tom Berenger as the little rancher taking on the big guys.  Covers the same territory Heaven's Gate did with better success.
TV Classic Westerns: Legends of the Old WestTV Classic Westerns: Legends of the Old West
Buy new: $15.99 / Used from: $8.93
*** - Pretty complete set of episodes from Jim Davis's (Jock Ewing of 'Dallas') 1954 TV series 'Stories of the Century'.  Undemanding entertainment that trends towards sameness.
A Man Called SledgeA Man Called Sledge
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $7.39
*** - James Garner is great but his performance is undermined by this muddled tale of robbery and greed.  Needed at least one more re-write.
Ned Blessing: Dead Man's RevengeNed Blessing: Dead Man's Revenge
Buy new: $5.99 / Used from: $2.57
**** - Two episodes of the short-lived 1993 CBS are great fun.  Good characters, acting, and lively plot make this one worth checking out.
Paint Your WagonPaint Your Wagon
Buy new: $7.99 / Used from: $3.99
***** - Much too long western musical that rambles muddily all over the place and contains maybe one - Maria - memorable song.  One of my favorite movies.  Go figure.
Painted Desert/Clark Gable on FilmPainted Desert/Clark Gable on Film
Buy used from: $4.99
* - Dreadful early talkie (1931) with William Boyd and Clark Gable (in his first talking movie.)
The ScalphuntersThe Scalphunters
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $4.89
**** - Fun Sydney Pollock comedy-western from 1968 features an energetic Burt Lancaster and an erudite Ossie Davis.
ShalakoShalako
Buy new: $9.98 / Used from: $1.59
** - Sean Connery and Brigitte Bardot fail to strike sparks in this lame adaptation of a Louis l'Amour novel.
TexasTexas
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $4.88
**** - Amiable and inconsequential 1941 showcase for then young and untested Glenn Ford and William Holden.  Strong cast also includes Claire Trevor and Edgar Buchanan.
To Build a FireTo Build a Fire
Buy new: $9.99 / Used from: $8.00
*** - Just okay television adaptation of classic Jack London short story.  Orson Welles provides the vital narration.
The TrackerThe Tracker
Buy new: $5.98 / Used from: $2.76
**** - (Mostly) good guy Kris Kristofferson tracks bad guy Scott Wilson in this well-done, 1988 HBO move.
El Tres de Copas (The Card of Luck Love and Death)El Tres de Copas (The Card of Luck Love and Death)
Buy new: $7.99 / Used from: $1.09
**** - Two mercenaries and a mysterious, beautiful woman combine for an oddly entertaining New Wave Mexican movie.
Vera CruzVera Cruz
Buy used from: $13.99
*** - Okay teaming of Burt Lancaster & Gary Cooper as two soldiers of fortune chasing gold south of the border.
WarlockWarlock
Buy new: $13.49 / Used from: $6.61
***** - Brilliant western about a small town hiring a pair of gunslinging vigilantes (Hank Fonda & Anthony Quinn) to bring peace to their troubled town.
Winchester '73Winchester '73
Buy new: $7.99 / Used from: $4.89
***** - First teaming of director Anthony Mann with Jimmy Stewart results in a classic western tale of revenge.  Essential viewing for western film fans.
Yellow Hair and the Fortress of GoldYellow Hair and the Fortress of Gold
Buy used from: $34.75
** - Flat and cheesy Indiana Jones rip-off has platinum blonde Apache beauty searching for a hidden cache of gold.