Listmania!
SALZBURG FESTIVAL MOZART M22 OVERVIEW AND ALTERNATE DVDS
By an Amazon.com customer
Mozart - The Salzburg Festspiele Opera BoxsetMozart - The Salzburg Festspiele Opera Boxset
Buy new: $485.99 / Used from: $415.47
See individual comments below.
Mozart - Apollo et Hyacinthus / Die Schuldigkeit des Ersten GebotsMozart - Apollo et Hyacinthus / Die Schuldigkeit des Ersten Gebots
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $23.99
Beautiful nearly authentic staging. The use of a modern telescope and magnifying glass is unfortunate, as replicas are available.
Mozart - Bastien und Bastienne / Der Schauspieldirector (The Impresario)Mozart - Bastien und Bastienne / Der Schauspieldirector (The Impresario)
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $23.16
Confusing fusion of two operas, more about the director than Mozart.
Mozart - La Finta SempliceMozart - La Finta Semplice
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $19.19
Superb ensemble performance that is true to Mozart's naughty side in spirit. Cheap costumes and brief nudity detract slighly. Viewers who are unwilling to accept Mozart's crude sense of humor will be offended. Very funny for the rest of us.
Mozart - MitridateMozart - Mitridate
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $32.23
Miah Persson is wonderful in this production that does not offer much worth looking at.
Mozart: Betulia LiberataMozart: Betulia Liberata
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $19.53
Not great Mozart, good performance. Julia Kleiter is a soprano to watch.
Mozart - Ascanio in AlbaMozart - Ascanio in Alba
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $23.16
Singing is not exceptional, but not bad. Staging is dysfunctional in my opinion. Chorus is dressed to look like robots or clean room workers. They march in and out of what looks like airlocks or clean rooms.
Mozart - Il Sogno di ScipioneMozart - Il Sogno di Scipione
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $17.22
Philosophical opera "sexed up" to the point of distraction. Fun,if you don't think about what this does to the plot. Only for those of us who can turn off critical thinking. Very difficult music that is a bit beyond what these singers can handle.
Mozart - Lucio SillaMozart - Lucio Silla
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $24.99
Nothing special, but not bad either. Julia Kleiter is wonderful.
Mozart - La Finta GiardinieraMozart - La Finta Giardiniera
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $20.98
A bit overdone, some semi nudity. See my review for details.
Mozart - Il Re pastoreMozart - Il Re pastore
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $17.89
Good reviews by others. Not a favorite opera for me. One of the better productions.
Mozart -   Lo Sposo Deluso / L'Oca del Cairo / Abendempfindungen / Rex TremendusMozart - Lo Sposo Deluso / L'Oca del Cairo / Abendempfindungen / Rex Tremendus
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $31.89
Bits and pieces mashed together with an annoying side show. Extreme example of a stage director venting his frustration with an impossible task. Buy this if you want proof that America is no longer a leader in bad taste, but don't try to watch the whole thing.
Mozart - IdomeneoMozart - Idomeneo
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $26.98
Clever modern production that makes this opera come to life. Several great young singers who are new to me. Great conducting as well. Nothing static or boring.
Mozart / Czernowin - Zaide / AdamaMozart / Czernowin - Zaide / Adama
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $19.98
Mozart's incomplete opera Zaide alternates with modern atonal connecting music. Disturbing staging. Not recommended, unless you have a taste for the truly bizzare.
Mozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem SerailMozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $26.10
A total perversion of the original story that is truly tastless. Nudity, real and simulated. Very nasty. Get any other DVD, my two favorites are listed below.
Mozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail / Ruth Ann Swenson, Malin Hartelius, Kurt Rydl, Hans Peter Blochwitz, Manfred Fink, Gianluigi Gelmetti, Schwetzingen OperaMozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail / Ruth Ann Swenson, Malin Hartelius, Kurt Rydl, Hans Peter Blochwitz, Manfred Fink, Gianluigi Gelmetti, Schwetzingen Opera
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $49.67
A beautiful authentic staging with great voices.
Mozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem SerailMozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $23.73
Great voices and traditional costumes in a regietheater setting.
Mozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail (The Abduction from the Seraglio) / Minkowski, Schafer, Groves, Tillawi, Salzburg FestivalMozart - Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail (The Abduction from the Seraglio) / Minkowski, Schafer, Groves, Tillawi, Salzburg Festival
Buy used from: $24.44
A fun regietheater version which is not true to the libretto but has a very interesting twist. An on stage water fight between Blonde (Malin Hartelius)and Osmin (Franz Hawlata) is worth the price of the disk.
Mozart - Le Nozze di FigaroMozart - Le Nozze di Figaro
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $22.66
A downbeat version of a comic opera. Not a good first version. I prefer Gardiner's lively one listed below.
Mozart - Le Nozze di Figaro (The Marriage of Figaro) / Jean-Louis Thamin · John Eliot Gardiner · Bryn Terfel · Rodney Gilfry · Théâtre du ChateletMozart - Le Nozze di Figaro (The Marriage of Figaro) / Jean-Louis Thamin · John Eliot Gardiner · Bryn Terfel · Rodney Gilfry · Théâtre du Chatelet
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $11.17
Very simple but effective staging. Good voices and acting. True to the libretto.
Mozart - Don GiovanniMozart - Don Giovanni
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $38.54
Confusing staging with extras in underware. Some truly dreadful costumes. Many better choices are available. My favorites are the 2006 Zurich DVD and the 1954 Salzburg film on DVD, both listed below. This is a complex opera that can be performed in different ways to great advantage.
Mozart - Don GiovanniMozart - Don Giovanni
Buy new: $22.49 / Used from: $16.48
This 2006 production from Zurich is elegant and earthy at the same time. For the most part it has a 1930 look, with costumes that complement this good looking cast. Singing is good to excellent. Welser-Moest conducts with a level of sensitivity seldom heard.
Mozart - Don Giovanni / FurtwanglerMozart - Don Giovanni / Furtwangler
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $14.94
If dated mono sound is not a problem, this famous film is most true to mozart's vision of the Don. Furtwangler's conducting is a bit slow in places, but the staging makes up for it by clearly following the libretto. Vocally superb.
Mozart - Cosi fan TutteMozart - Cosi fan Tutte
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $11.59
A rather confused staging with little sense of ensemble. Everyone does their own thing without much relating to others. Great conducting. Strongly recommend La Scala DVD below, even though sound is not quite as good. This will only be noticed by direct comparison on very good equipment.
Mozart - Cosi fan Tutte / Dessi, Ziegler, Corbelli, Scarabelli, Kundlak, Desderi; Muti, La Scala OperaMozart - Cosi fan Tutte / Dessi, Ziegler, Corbelli, Scarabelli, Kundlak, Desderi; Muti, La Scala Opera
Buy new: $17.99 / Used from: $11.50
My pick for the best Cosi Fan Tutte.
Mozart - Die ZauberfloteMozart - Die Zauberflote
Buy new: $35.99 / Used from: $23.35
Dr Seuss childrens book costumes and bright saturated colors detract from a beautiful performance. Staging makes following the story difficult. Although my first picks are vocally less exciting, they are true to Mozart's intentions. One can emphasize the Masonic symbols or the comic/magic elements.
The Magic Flute - Criterion CollectionThe Magic Flute - Criterion Collection
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $16.95
Beautiful Bergman film, sung in Swedish. Best for Family viewing, as there is no nudity. More politically correct than other versions.
Mozart - Die Zauberflote / Hartelius, Beczala, Salminen, Mosuc, Schaginger, Neumann, Keller, Vogel, Will, Welser-Most, Zurich OperaMozart - Die Zauberflote / Hartelius, Beczala, Salminen, Mosuc, Schaginger, Neumann, Keller, Vogel, Will, Welser-Most, Zurich Opera
Buy new: $26.99 / Used from: $13.50
Most intellectual version which is short on scenery, yet features the masonic part of the story. Pamina and Papageno are superb, but Queen of the Night is no match for Damrau on M22 above. Other singers are very good, but not exceptional. Very logical production, once you get past the bare chested serpent bearer in the opening.
Mozart - La Clemenza di Tito / Dorothea Roschmann, Michael Schade, Barbara Bonney, Elina Garanca, Vesselina Kasarova, Nikolaus Harnoncourt, Salzburg OperaMozart - La Clemenza di Tito / Dorothea Roschmann, Michael Schade, Barbara Bonney, Elina Garanca, Vesselina Kasarova, Nikolaus Harnoncourt, Salzburg Opera
Buy new: $31.49 / Used from: $17.95
Great singing. Harnoncourt conducts well but too slowly for my taste, There is no "punch". Singers reveal their underware (which changes) each time they remove their jackets. Too many modern silly distractions in this very spread out all over the place production. My pick is the Zurich DVD below. Simple staging with no underware display. Kaufmann is a great Tito.
Mozart - La Clemenza di Tito (Opernhaus Zurich 2005)Mozart - La Clemenza di Tito (Opernhaus Zurich 2005)
Buy new: $22.49 / Used from: $22.69
A very dynamic performance in beautiful sound. Sometimes the orchestra overtakes the voices, but the overall effect is thrilling. This is the first time I got a sense of how close Mozart came to being as dramatic as Beethoven. Staging is simple, somewhat dark, yet very effective. Some listeners have been disapointed by Eva Mei as Vitellia, but I find most of her singing excellent.
Mozart - La clemenza di Tito / Rolfe Johnson, Varady, von Otter, McNair, Robbin, Hauptmann, English Baroque Soloists, GardinerMozart - La clemenza di Tito / Rolfe Johnson, Varady, von Otter, McNair, Robbin, Hauptmann, English Baroque Soloists, Gardiner
Buy used from: $28.91
My former favorite recording of Clemenza.